Broadband Internet Information Information Research

Tell a Friend about this Site

Compare Cable vs. DSL


Okay, so you are finally tired of those slow dial-up internet connections, and you want to go broadband. Good deal. But first, you may be wondering which type of broadband connection is best- DSL or Cable? Or, at least, which of the two gives you more speed for the price? Here we take a look at these two popular broadband connections and try to determine which one is better: DSL vs. Cable.

Cable Speed vs. DSL

The most common question that comes up is which type of connection is faster, DSL or Cable? To answer this, it is important to compare both upload and download speeds. Now, so you have something to compare these speeds to, your average dial-up connection is about 28 - 56 Kbps. Most often, however, you won't be able to get 56k through dial up, as most services can not handle this speed.

The average speed of a DSL download is 1.0 - 1.5Mbps. That's megabytes per second - about 20 times as fast as the fastest dial-up connection. This is fast, but consider Cable, which can give you up to 2 - 3Mbps. Thus, at least for downloading, cable can give you almost twice the speed of DSL - that's impressive. On the upload side, however, cable and DSL are pretty evenly matched. They both provide about 100Kbps - 400Kbps. It seems that cable has won this battle.

What about Price and Quality of Service?

There is more to discuss here besides the speed of the connections. Take price for one. Cable and DSL connections are both going to be more expensive than dial-up. But, DSL seems to be the cheaper of the two at the moment. You can get a good DSL internet connection for about $35 - $45 per month. Cable modem will cost you about $45 or $50 (this price may be included in a cable TV package). These prices, however, are really close and they change almost from month to month.

DSL is nice because you can talk on the phone and be online at the same time. In addition, business-level DSL service provides guaranteed data rates, so your connection speed is never a surprise. On the other hand, DSL speed tends to decrease the further you are away from the data center, and it is typically not as widely available as Cable. Cable speeds are not dependent on distance from the data center, and is occasionally cheaper than DSL when included in a cable TV rate. A cable modem, however, may require costly professional installation, and there may exists some limitations on downloads and uploads. All of these factors should be taken into consideration when choosing either broadband service.

Bradley James is a senior editor at SciNet.cc, a website containing many helpful consumer electronics review articles. For more information on DSL and Cable technology, please visit our DSL vs Cable webpage.


MORE RESOURCES:

Los Angeles Times

FCC's plan for broadband Internet access falls short
Washington Post
The government has a big plan for broadband -- big enough that you'll want a broadband connection to download its full text. ...
FCC Plans National Access To Broadband InternetRed, White, and Blue Press (blog)
How fast is your broadband? Even the feds can't be sureLos Angeles Times
Plan Aims to Expand Broadband Across USVoice of America
Payson Roundup -Watching the Watchers.org (blog) -Delmarva Daily Times
all 144 news articles »


Jim Sconyers: Broadband Internet coming -- but not to us?
Charleston Gazette
Manchin and President Obama are both talking about new initiatives to extend high-speed broadband Internet access, one for West Virginia and the other ...



The Grand Rapids Press - MLive.com

Hoping to Attract Google? Go Jump in the Lake
New York Times
The mayor of Duluth, Minn., threw himself into the ice-ringed waters of Lake Superior. The mayor of Sarasota, Fla., immersed himself in a ...
Citywide Wi-FiTexas A&M The Battalion
From the news deskHometownlife.com
City tries for Google trialPalladium-Item
Daily Journal of Commerce -TMCnet
all 53 news articles »


Kansas City Star

FCC plan would greatly expand broadband Internet connections
Washington Post
The Federal Communications Commission announced on Monday its long-awaited plan to bring broadband Internet connections to every home and ...
Local officials praise broadband Internet proposalDaily American Online
A new right for Americans: universal broadband InternetExaminer.com
US plan for broadband Internet releasedWikinews
Ozarks First -AllGov -WCNC (subscription)
all 2,364 news articles »


PC World

The Future of American Broadband
Tom's Guide
If you're an avid reader of Tom's Guide and Tom's Hardware, chances are you're already hooked into a broadband internet connection of some sort, ...
Statistics Reveals Only 3,6% of People Do not Have High Speed Internet ConnectionLatest Gadgets (blog)
FCC Wrestles Private Interests for the Public GoodPC World
FCC and Future Of American Broadband CoverageSeven Sided Cube
Pittsburgh Post Gazette -TechCrunch (blog) -Fort Wayne Journal Gazette
all 54 news articles »


Prince William seeks to be lab for Google's speedy Internet
Washington Post
Prince William County will vie for a spot in a nationwide trial that Google plans to launch of "ultra high-speed" broadband Internet, ...

and more »


Russia's Broadband Internet Use Rising, Even Afar -Vedomosti
FOXBusiness
Broadband Internet use in Russia is spreading beyond major cities to the vast regions, according to a new study, business daily Vedomosti reports Thursday. ...

and more »


Everything Long Beach (press release)

City Vies for Trial of Google's Broadband Internet
Santa Monica Mirror
The City of Santa Monica is preparing an application to participate in a trial of ultra-high speed broadband networks offered by Google. ...
EDITORIAL: A chance at advancementPlattsburgh Press Republican
Luján backs Farmington's Google proposalThe New Mexico Independent
Orcas organizer wants Google's ultra-high speed Internet in the San JuansJournal of the San Jaun Islands
O'Reilly Radar (blog) -Record-Searchlight
all 113 news articles »


Reuters

Broadband Internet service narrows the gap between urban and rural areas
Kansas City Star
The Federal Communications Commission estimates that 96 percent of Americans at least have the option to subscribe to broadband Internet service. ...
FCC wants 90% of US with broadband InternetTuscaloosa News (subscription) (blog)
FCC broadband plan: It must spur competitionChristian Science Monitor
FCC Pushes For Universally Accessible Nationwide WirelessHot Hardware
AOL News -Radio Survivor (blog) -TechSpot
all 205 news articles »


New Funding Will Expand Broadband Internet Service In Jackson...
KEYC
Good evening, I'm Dion Cheney.And I'm Nicole Winters.Thanks for joining us.The stimulus bill passed last year is still creating projects throughout the ...

and more »

Google News



MaineBannerExchange

home | site map
© 2006