Management Information Information Research

Tell a Friend about this Site

The "Better People" Fallacy


It's easy enough to convince your own staff that better people will prevail, even against the odds. It's what they want to hear. And surely in a marketing war quality is a factor as well as quantity.

It is, but superiority of force is such an overwhelming advantage that it overcomes most quality differences.

We have no doubt that the poorest team in the National Football League could consistently beat the best team in the NFL if it could field 12 men against the opposition's 11.

In business, where the teams are much larger, your ability to amass a quality difference is much more difficult.

The clear-thinking marketing manager won't confuse the pep talk at a sales rally with the reality of the marketing area. A good general never makes military strategy based on having better personnel. Nor should a marketing general. ("Our army," said Wellington "is composed of the scum of the earth, the mere scum of the earth.")

Obviously you'd be in deep trouble inside your company if you used Wellington's words to describe your own army. Tell your people how terrific they are, but don't plan on winning the battle with superior personnel.

Count on winning the battle with a superior strategy.

Yet many companies cling deeply to the better people strategy. They're convinced they can recruit and hire substantially better training programs can help them keep their "people" edge.

Any student of statistics would laugh at this belief. Sure, it's possible to put together a small cadre of superior people. But the larger the company, the more likely the average employee will be average.

And when it comes to the mega companies, the possibility of assembling an intellectually superior team becomes statistically almost zero.

At last count, IBM had 369,545 employees, a number which is growing rapidly. On a one-to-one basic, there may be more white shirts at IBM but not more gray matter.

IBM is winning the computer war the Eisenhower way. Where the competition has 2, IBM has 4. Where the competition has 4, IBM has 8.

Arvind Kumar is an Electrical Engineer from a premier Institute, Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi, India. He has 3 years experince in marketing business consulting services and marketing services. He is founder and CEO of http://www.nuttymarketer.com. You may reach him at arvind@nuttymarketer.com.


MORE RESOURCES:

AFP

Economy: Small Comfort in Manufacturing Uptick
AlterNet, CA - 4 hours ago
Last week, the private sector Institute for Supply Management (ISM) bucked economists' expectations and said the manufacturing sector last month clawed its ...
ISM Manufacturing Goes into Expansion Mode; AP Changes Subject NewsBusters
Service sector shrinks unexpectedly Reuters
From The Economist print edition Economist
CNNMoney.com - MarketWatch
all 428 news articles


Inhabitat

BLM considers grouse boundaries
In-Forum, ND - 2 hours ago
AP - Saturday, July 05, 2008 The US Bureau of Land Management plans to take a few extra weeks to consider existing coal-bed methane facilities in the Powder ...
US government lifts ban on new solar plants Dallas Morning News
Solar farms' impact to be explained Arizona Daily Star
Bureau Of Land Management Backpedals On Solar Moratorium Solar Industry
Slashdot - San Francisco Chronicle
all 257 news articles


Lodging Hospitality Management to invest $9M in Collinsville hotel
Bizjournals.com, NC - Jul 3, 2008
Lodging Hospitality Management paid $5.3 million to the state of Illinois for the Collinsville Holiday Inn property in Collinsville, Ill., and is planning ...
State sells troubled Collinsville Holiday Inn to hotel management ... Belleville News Democrat
Collinsville Holiday Inn sold North County Journal
State unloads hotel after losing millions Chicago Tribune
Tri County Journal - Belleville News Democrat
all 24 news articles


Times Online

Management Today’s ‘35 Women Under 35’ 2008
Times Online, UK - 1 hour ago
This includes inventor Tanya Budd, who at 20 is the youngest in Management Today’s “35 Women Under 35” list since its inception in 2001. ...


Part of SD Badlands management could go to American Indian tribe
KMEG 14, IA - 2 hours ago
AP - July 5, 2008 5:15 PM ET BADLANDS NATIONAL PARK, SD (AP) - The National Park Service is taking input on what could be a first -- turning over management ...


Credit crunch: UBS piles $7.5bn on to its write-down bill
guardian.co.uk, UK - Jul 4, 2008
UBS said its wealth management/business banking and asset management divisions were profitable in the second quarter but conceded that it had seen an ...
Subprime-hit UBS says could break even second quarter AFP
ANALYSIS-UBS gets brief respite as strategic worries build Forbes
UBS Says It May Avoid Loss, Doesn't Need More Capital (Update2) Bloomberg
International Herald Tribune - TheStreet.com
all 362 news articles


Disaster management tackle township floods
Independent Online, South Africa - 16 hours ago
By Bronwynne Jooste and Nwabisa Msutwana-Stemela The city of Cape Town's disaster management has assisted hundreds of families who were affected by the ...
Bad weather sets in for Cape Town SABC News
No flood evacuations in CT yet News24
Cape Peninsula braces itself for weekend floods SABC News
all 15 news articles


Thomson Financial Europe AM at a glance share guide: Shares mixed ...
Forbes, NY - Jul 3, 2008
The Institute for Supply Management said its index of service sector activity fell to 48.2 from 51.7 in May; the reading touched off more misgivings about ...
Service sector contracts as orders fall The Associated Press
Service sector contracts WBTV
Opening Glance: Shares of commercial banks slide Forbes
all 148 news articles


Liberty Bank, NA announces management promotions; Donald Waytes ...
dBusinessNews Austin (press release), TX - 2 hours ago
CLEVELAND - Beachwood-based Liberty Bank, NA today announced three management promotions. Donald M. Waytes, Jr. was promoted from Commercial Credit Analyst ...


Goal.com

Mancini Turns To Hotel Management?
Goal.com, Switzerland - 4 hours ago
Former Inter coach Roberto Mancini is finding plenty of things to do after getting the sack from president Massimo Moratti, even though close friends reveal ...

Management - Google News



MaineBannerExchange

home | site map
© 2006